Economic Challenges in Pakistan: Causes and Solutions

Opening Remarks

Pakistan's economy has been on a rollercoaster ride for years, with ups and downs that affect everyday life, investments, and the broader financial health of the nation. From persistent inflation squeezing household budgets to unemployment rates that leave many skilled workers idle, the challenges are as tangled as ever.

Understanding these economic issues isn’t just for economists or policymakers — traders, investors, financial analysts, educators, and brokers all stand to gain from a clear-eyed view of what's happening and the possible ways forward.

popular

This article aims to cut through the noise by focusing on four big hurdles: inflation, unemployment, fiscal policies, and the dynamics of foreign trade. Each of these affects Pakistan's economy in tangible ways, influencing decisions at every level — from government strategies to individual investments.

We’ll look at the root causes behind these challenges, what impact they have on the economy, and most importantly, what practical steps can be taken to manage them effectively. Whether you're monitoring the Karachi Stock Exchange or advising clients on portfolio adjustments, this guide provides insights anchored in current realities and data.

Economic challenges in Pakistan are complex but not insurmountable. Recognizing the factors at play lays the groundwork for smarter decisions and more resilient financial planning.

In the sections ahead, we’ll break down each topic with real-world examples, relevant statistics, and hands-on advice tailored to stakeholders across the financial and economic spectrum in Pakistan.

Overview of Pakistan's Economic Landscape

Pakistan's economic landscape is the bedrock for understanding the challenges the country faces. This section is about grasping where the economy stands right now by breaking down key figures like GDP, inflation, and employment. By getting a solid handle on these numbers, traders, investors, and analysts can make smarter decisions—whether it’s spotting investment opportunities or anticipating market shifts.

Current Economic Indicators

GDP growth trends

Pakistan’s GDP growth has been a rollercoaster over the last decade, swinging from highs around 5-6% pre-pandemic to sluggish or even negative rates during tough periods. Recently, growth hovers near 3-4%, reflecting both internal issues and global shocks. Tracking GDP trends isn’t just about big numbers; it tells you how the economy expands or contracts, which sectors are driving growth, and where bottlenecks lie. For example, if manufacturing output spikes while agriculture lags, investors might lean towards industrial stocks or related ventures.

Inflation rate analysis

Inflation in Pakistan has often been a headache, running upwards of 10% at times. High inflation eats away purchasing power and can force the State Bank to hike interest rates, slowing growth. Understanding the inflation rate helps businesses and consumers plan better: if prices for essentials like wheat or fuel rise sharply, it shifts spending patterns and raises costs for producers. Monitoring inflation also gives clues about monetary policy directions and currency stability.

Employment statistics

Employment figures reveal underlying economic health. Pakistan struggles with high youth unemployment and a large informal sector where many work but without job security or benefits. These stats show who’s active in the labor market and where gaps exist, crucial for designing workforce policies. For businesses, knowing employment trends helps fine-tune recruitment or predict consumer demand. An uptick in formal sector jobs might signal better wage growth ahead, potentially boosting consumer spending.

Historical Context of Economic Challenges

Past financial crises

Pakistan has faced several financial crises—from the debt burden of the 1990s to currency crashes and IMF bailouts. These events are not just history lessons; they offer practical insight into what went wrong and how policy responses shaped recovery. For instance, the 2008 global crisis hit hard, with the Pakistani rupee plunging and foreign reserves tight. Learning from these moments reveals patterns, such as reliance on short-term borrowing or vulnerability to oil price shocks, which remain relevant today.

Structural economic changes

Over time, Pakistan’s economy shifted from predominantly agriculture to a more mixed setup, including textiles, manufacturing, and services. However, this shift has been uneven, with some sectors growing fast while others lag behind due to outdated infrastructure or policy gaps. Recognizing these structural changes is key for investors scouting growth sectors, policymakers drafting reforms, or educators aligning skill development with market needs. For example, the rise of the IT sector reveals new opportunities but also demands updated training initiatives.

Understanding Pakistan's economic landscape is like getting a snapshot of the country’s financial health. Without it, any effort to tackle challenges is like flying blind.

By mastering these foundational elements, you build a clear picture of where Pakistan stands economically, setting the stage for deeper dives into inflation, unemployment, and policy impacts discussed in the sections ahead.

Factors Contributing to Economic Instability

Economic instability in Pakistan is a significant hurdle that affects every sector, from small businesses to large investors. Understanding these factors helps us see why things get shaky sometimes and what that means in practice. In this section, we’ll look at two critical contributors: inflation and unemployment, which both play a major role in shaking up the country’s economic balance.

Inflation and Its Impact on Daily Life

Causes of Inflation in Pakistan

Inflation in Pakistan typically boils down to a mix of supply chain disruptions, monetary policy decisions, and external shocks like rising oil prices. For instance, when international oil prices spike, fuel costs rise here too, pushing up the prices of everything that depends on transportation—from food to clothing. Add to that the government borrowing heavily and printing money, which can flood the market with more currency chasing the same goods, and you get price hikes.

The agricultural sector also plays a role; bad weather can spoil harvests causing food prices to soar. Plus, high import bills and a weakening rupee can make imports costlier, adding to overall inflation. Understanding these causes helps traders and investors anticipate price changes and adjust their strategies accordingly.

Effects on Purchasing Power and Households

Inflation eats away at the purchasing power of everyday citizens, hitting low and middle-income families hardest. When prices rise faster than wages, families find themselves cutting back on essentials or going without some goods altogether. For instance, a family that used to afford monthly groceries comfortably might now skip items or switch to cheaper alternatives.

This squeeze can reduce consumer spending, slowing down the economy further. For financial analysts, it’s important to watch inflation trends closely, as prolonged inflation can lead to lower saving rates and higher borrowing costs. Households often turn to informal borrowing to meet daily expenses, which can trap them in debt cycles.

Inflation acts like a hidden tax on households, quietly draining their wallets and forcing tough choices on daily essentials.

Unemployment Dynamics and Labor Market Issues

Youth Unemployment Trends

Young people in Pakistan face a tough job market, with youth unemployment rates often much higher than the national average. The growing population means more young people enter the workforce each year, but the formal sector can't absorb them quickly enough. Many graduates end up stuck waiting for jobs that match their skills, or they settle for underemployment.

This trend isn’t just about numbers; it impacts social stability and economic productivity. Youth without jobs are less likely to invest or consume, which stalls growth and innovation. Policymakers and educators need to focus on closing the gap between education and market needs, helping young workers gain relevant skills to navigate the changing job landscape.

Challenges in Formal and Informal Sectors

Pakistan’s labor market is split between a small formal sector and a large informal economy. The formal sector offers some job security and benefits but is limited in size, especially for unskilled workers. The informal sector, which includes street vendors, domestic workers, and casual laborers, lacks regulation, making incomes volatile and unpredictable.

Workers in the informal economy often don’t have contracts or social safety nets, making them vulnerable during economic downturns. This divide creates a challenge for the government, as informal workers contribute less to tax revenue but represent a big chunk of the workforce. Improving labor laws and formalizing parts of the informal sector could help stabilize incomes and stimulate economic resilience.

Clear awareness of these economic instability factors helps investors and financial professionals make smarter decisions and encourages policymakers to craft better solutions. Inflation and unemployment aren’t just numbers; they shape daily life and market conditions profoundly.

Government Fiscal Policies and Budget Management

When we look at Pakistan's economic health, government fiscal policies and budget management play a huge role. These policies dictate how the government balances its income and spending, which directly impacts everything from inflation rates to public services. In simple terms, how the government handles its money can either stabilize or shake the economy. For traders, investors, and financial analysts, understanding these policies is like having a roadmap to the country's economic direction.

Revenue Generation Strategies

Tax system overview

Pakistan relies heavily on its tax system to generate the revenue needed for government operations and development projects. The tax system includes direct taxes like income tax and indirect taxes such as sales tax and customs duties. One key challenge is the low tax-to-GDP ratio, hovering around 12%, which is quite below the global average. This limits the government's ability to fund essential services or invest in infrastructure.

For practical insight, consider how widening the tax base and improving tax collection could boost revenue without putting extra strain on already taxed segments. For example, better compliance from small businesses and informal sectors could bring in fresh revenue streams. Understanding tax policies helps investors predict government spending patterns and potential market impacts.

Non-tax revenue sources

Besides taxes, the government pulls in revenue from other sources like profits from state-owned enterprises (SOEs), fees, fines, and dividends from investments in companies. For instance, Pakistan’s Pakistan International Airlines (PIA) and Pakistan State Oil contribute to government coffers, though their profitability fluctuates.

This non-tax revenue is crucial to bridge gaps where tax collection falls short. It offers an additional cushion for fiscal management, especially in tight economic conditions. Keeping an eye on SOE performance can alert investors and traders to potential budgetary risks or fixes.

Expenditure Priorities and Deficit Concerns

Public spending allocations

Where the government decides to spend its money reveals priorities and affects economic stability. In Pakistan, a large slice of the budget goes to debt servicing, defense, and subsidies, leaving limited funds for health, education, or infrastructure.

popular

For example, prioritizing subsidies on energy or food impacts inflation but may limit long-term investments in sectors that could drive growth, like technology or manufacturing. Efficient allocation means balancing immediate relief with growth support. Financial analysts pay close attention to these decisions as they affect market confidence and economic prospects.

Managing budget deficits

Pakistan consistently runs budget deficits, meaning the government's expenses surpass its revenues. Financing these gaps often involves borrowing from domestic banks or external creditors. However, excessive borrowing can lead to rising debt, higher interest payments, and currency pressures.

Effective management requires a two-pronged approach: controlling unnecessary expenditures while boosting revenue without hurting economic activity. For instance, cutting down on non-essential imports and improving tax compliance can ease deficits. Investors watch these moves because persistent deficits may trigger austerity measures or foreign exchange crises.

Balancing revenue and spending is a tightrope walk for Pakistan’s policymakers. For market participants, understanding how fiscal policy shapes the economic landscape is essential to making informed decisions.

In summary, government fiscal policies and budget management hold the reins of Pakistan's economic challenges. A well-structured tax system, diverse revenue sources, prudent spending, and careful deficit control are critical bricks in building a resilient economy.

Role of Foreign Trade and Investment

Foreign trade and investment play a significant role in shaping Pakistan’s economic landscape. For a country struggling with issues like fiscal deficits and unemployment, opening doors to global markets and foreign capital is like giving the economy a breath of fresh air. This section aims to break down how trade and investment influence growth and stability, and why these components matter for traders, investors, financial analysts, and policymakers alike.

Trade Balance and Export Challenges

Key export commodities

Pakistan’s export mix is crucial for understanding the trade balance. The country heavily relies on a few commodities, such as textiles (especially cotton garments), rice, and surgical instruments. For instance, textiles make up over 60% of Pakistan's exports, providing jobs to millions but leaving the economy vulnerable to global market shifts or changes in demand. A drop in international orders can quickly ripple through the economy, affecting livelihoods and government revenues.

Diversifying export goods is essential. Adding products like processed foods, leather goods, and pharmaceuticals could reduce the risk of over-reliance on textiles. Government and business sectors need to collaborate here, enhancing product quality and meeting international standards, so Pakistani goods stand out globally.

Trade deficits and causes

Pakistan consistently runs a trade deficit, meaning it imports more than it exports. This gap drains foreign reserves and pressures the currency. The main causes include dependence on oil imports for energy needs and limited export diversity.

A practical example is Pakistan’s reliance on importing machinery and raw materials, which are not yet produced locally. Improving domestic production capabilities and focusing on export competitiveness could shrink the trade deficit. Additionally, inefficient customs procedures and logistics add cost and delay, hampering export growth and discouraging foreign buyers.

Addressing trade imbalances is like balancing a checkbook. Running a persistent deficit is manageable in short bursts but becomes problematic if left unchecked, affecting currency stability and inflation.

Foreign Direct Investment and Economic Growth

Investment climate

A welcoming investment climate encourages foreign companies to bring capital, technology, and jobs. Pakistan offers potential due to its youthful population and strategic location near major markets like China and the Middle East. However, concerns remain about political instability, security risks, and bureaucratic red tape.

For example, despite huge potential in sectors like energy and telecommunications, uncertainty keeps many investors at bay. Streamlining regulations and ensuring consistent policy enforcement can boost confidence, drawing more foreign direct investment (FDI) that fuels economic growth.

Policies to attract investors

To woo investors, Pakistan has undertaken several initiatives, such as relaxed foreign ownership rules and tax incentives in special economic zones (SEZs). But more is needed beyond incentives. Transparent legal processes, protection of investor rights, and reducing corruption can change investor perceptions.

A practical step is improving the ease of doing business, making official procedures less time-consuming and costly. Countries like Vietnam have set examples by simplifying company registration and cutting down paperwork, which has attracted foreign companies, created jobs, and spurred growth. Matching these efforts would go a long way.

Well-crafted policies make a real difference. They don’t just sit on paper but create an environment where foreign capital feels safe and can genuinely contribute to the economy.

By understanding trade balances, export challenges, and the role of foreign investment, stakeholders can better navigate Pakistan’s economic waters, pushing toward growth and stability despite existing hurdles.

Monetary Policy and Currency Stability

Monetary policy and currency stability play a fundamental role in shaping Pakistan's economic environment. For traders, investors, and financial analysts alike, understanding these factors is essential because they directly influence inflation rates, interest costs, investment confidence, and the overall business climate. Currency value impacts import-export pricing, debt servicing, and purchasing power, making it critical to grasp how monetary authorities manage these forces.

Central Bank's Role

Interest Rate Management

The State Bank of Pakistan (SBP) regulates interest rates to control money supply and stabilize the economy. Adjusting the policy rate helps control inflation and stimulates or cools economic activity. For instance, raising benchmark rates can slow down borrowing and spending, easing inflationary pressures. Conversely, lowering rates encourages investment and consumption by making loans cheaper.

Interest rate changes affect loan repayments for businesses and consumers and influence foreign investment decisions. When SBP hikes rates, foreign investors might be tempted by higher returns, helping strengthen the currency. However, it can also increase costs for local borrowers, especially SMEs, creating a balancing act for policymakers.

Inflation Targeting

Pakistan's central bank adopts inflation targeting as a way to keep price increases within a manageable range, typically aiming for around 6% annually. This approach provides predictability for businesses and consumers, helping them make informed financial decisions.

By focusing on inflation, the SBP can align monetary policy with economic realities. For example, if inflation spikes due to rising commodity prices or currency depreciation, the bank may tighten policy to prevent spiraling costs. Clear communication about inflation targets also builds credibility and expectations, preventing panic-driven price hikes or wage demands.

Exchange Rate Fluctuations

Impact on Imports and Exports

Currency fluctuations significantly impact Pakistan's trade balance. A weaker rupee makes imports costlier, raising prices for raw materials and consumer goods. This can squeeze manufacturers who rely on imported inputs and lead to broader inflation. At the same time, a depreciated currency boosts exports by making Pakistani goods cheaper overseas, potentially increasing foreign currency inflows.

For example, when the rupee fell sharply in 2023, the price of imported machinery and fuel surged, pushing up production costs. However, textile exporters saw greater demand because their products became more affordable in international markets. Traders and brokers must watch these trends closely, as exchange rate changes can alter profit margins and competitive positioning.

Strategies for Currency Stabilization

Stabilizing the rupee requires a mix of monetary policy tools and foreign exchange interventions. The SBP often uses its reserves to buy or sell dollars, smoothing sharp swings. Introducing flexible exchange rate regimes also helps absorb external shocks without severe disruption.

Additionally, policies encouraging foreign direct investment (FDI), export diversification, and remittance inflows can build reserves and reduce volatility. For example, Pakistan's attempts to attract Chinese investments via the China-Pakistan Economic Corridor aim to improve currency stability by boosting foreign capital.

Maintaining a stable currency alongside sound monetary policy boosts investor confidence and protects the economy from unpredictable shocks, which is vital for long-term growth.

In summary, monetary policy and currency stability are not just technical topics. They shape everyday business costs, investment returns, and economic welfare. For anyone involved in Pakistan's financial markets, keeping an eye on the State Bank's actions and currency trends is indispensable for making smart decisions.

Socioeconomic Impacts of Economic Challenges

Understanding the socioeconomic impacts of Pakistan’s economic difficulties is vital because these challenges don't just stay on the balance sheets; they trickle down into real-world effects on people's lives. When inflation bites or unemployment spikes, it directly influences poverty rates, income inequality, education quality, and skill development – all of which are the foundation stones of a functioning economy. Grasping these effects helps policymakers and investors anticipate potential social unrest or shifts in the labor market and design more informed interventions.

Poverty and Income Inequality

Measuring poverty levels

In Pakistan, poverty measurement isn’t just about counting who earns below a certain number; it’s a more nuanced process that includes examining access to basic needs like food, shelter, and healthcare. The commonly used poverty line often varies, and this makes tracking progress tricky. For example, the Pakistan Bureau of Statistics uses different thresholds to account for rural versus urban poverty. Getting these measures right means government strategies can better target those genuinely in need.

Accurate poverty metrics guide community programs and international aid, directing funds where they are most effective.

Government support programs

To cushion the blow of economic hardships, Pakistan’s government has launched various initiatives like the Ehsaas Program and Benazir Income Support Program. These programs offer cash transfers, healthcare subsidies, and job training to vulnerable groups. Their impact is significant but sometimes limited by implementation challenges, such as delayed payments or targeting errors. Improving tracking and expanding outreach, especially to remote areas, can enhance their effectiveness.

Education and Workforce Skills Development

Link between education and economy

Education in Pakistan is more than a social good — it’s an investment. A better-educated workforce tends to attract more foreign investment and fosters innovation. Right now, gaps in education quality reflect directly in the economy’s ability to grow. For instance, companies often complain about fresh graduates lacking practical skills, which slows down productivity.

Improving vocational training

Vocational training offers a practical fix. By focusing on trades and technical skills that align with Pakistan’s economic needs, like information technology or textile manufacturing, vocational institutes can help plug labor market gaps. Expanding partnerships between industry and training centers can ensure these programs train workers in what employers actually want.

Strengthening vocational training boosts youth employment and helps tackle the mismatch between education output and job market demand.

Together, tackling poverty, inequality, and education deficits will pave the way toward a more resilient Pakistani economy where everyone has a fair shake at prosperity.

Strategies for Sustainable Economic Growth

Economic growth isn't just about numbers ticking upward on a chart; it’s about creating a stable, lasting foundation for a country’s future. In Pakistan’s case, sustainable growth means building an economy that can weather shocks—like fluctuating commodity prices or political changes—while creating genuine opportunities for its people. Sustainable strategies focus on long-term benefits instead of quick fixes, ensuring prosperity lasts beyond immediate gains.

Diversification of Economy

Promoting new sectors

Relying heavily on a narrow set of industries has left Pakistan vulnerable to external shocks and slow growth. Diversifying the economy means encouraging development in sectors like technology, renewable energy, and tourism, which have been relatively neglected despite their potential. For instance, Pakistan’s budding tech startups in cities such as Karachi and Lahore promise a fresh injection of innovation and jobs. Government incentives, like tax breaks and startup incubators, can boost these new sectors.

Encouraging sectors beyond traditional manufacturing and textiles reduces risks tied to global demand fluctuations. This also improves export variety, opening doors to more stable and higher-value markets. Traders and investors often see diversified economies as less risky, which can promote more foreign investment.

Reducing dependence on agriculture

Agriculture has been the backbone of Pakistan's economy but leaning too much on it limits growth prospects. Factors like unpredictable weather and outdated farming methods make agriculture a less reliable income source. Shifting focus to manufacturing and service industries can raise productivity and income levels.

By developing agro-processing industries, Pakistan can add value locally rather than just exporting raw products. For example, turning cotton into finished clothing rather than exporting raw cotton pockets more revenue and jobs. This shift also encourages urbanization and workforce development, which are vital for moving up the economic ladder. Reducing dependence on agriculture means Pakistan avoids being stuck in the cycle of low wages and seasonal unemployment common in farming.

Encouraging Small and Medium Enterprises (SMEs)

Access to finance

One of the biggest hurdles for SMEs in Pakistan is securing adequate financing. These businesses drive a large chunk of employment but often struggle to get loans due to strict collateral requirements and high interest rates. Improving access means not only more capital but also financial products tailored to local needs, like microloans or flexible repayment plans.

Banks like Habib Bank Limited and Fintech firms such as Karandaaz Pakistan are stepping in to fill this gap, offering SME-focused credit lines and digital financial services. These efforts must expand to reach rural entrepreneurs and women-owned businesses as well, which are traditionally underserved.

"When SMEs thrive, the whole economy benefits—innovation increases, employment grows, and poverty declines."

Business environment reforms

Ease of doing business is a top factor that attracts both local entrepreneurs and foreign investors. Pakistani SMEs often face bureaucratic red tape, from registering businesses to paying taxes. Simplifying these processes through online portals and clear guidelines would lower the barrier to starting and scaling businesses.

Reforms should also include stronger legal protections for contracts and property rights, so investors feel more secure. Karachi Stock Exchange’s modernization efforts show how institutional updates can boost confidence. Reducing corruption and improving transparency aligns with this goal, promoting fair competition and healthier market dynamics.

Together, better financing access and a friendlier business climate give SMEs the boost needed for sustainable contributions to Pakistan's economy. By broadening the economic base and strengthening the middle layer of enterprises, Pakistan can lay down a more resilient economic path for years ahead.

Policy Recommendations and Future Outlook

Addressing Pakistan's economic challenges isn't just about quick fixes; it requires a solid roadmap that points towards sustainable progress. The section on policy recommendations and future outlook digs into what practical steps can be taken to stabilize the economy and foster growth in the long run. This is vital for traders, investors, and analysts because a clear policy direction reduces uncertainty and builds confidence in markets.

Concrete reforms, when backed by strong institutions and regional cooperation, can help steer the economy away from volatility. For example, without transparent governance or consistent trade policies, foreign investors may think twice before committing funds, prolonging economic instability. Thus, exploring actionable recommendations here gives a sneak peek into the future trajectory of Pakistan's economy, preparing stakeholders to make informed decisions.

Strengthening Institutional Frameworks

Transparency and Accountability

For any economic system, transparency in government operations and accountability of officials are non-negotiable. Basically, it means that decisions, budgets, and project implementations should be open for scrutiny, preventing fund mismanagement or corruption. When institutions operate transparently, public trust grows, encouraging higher tax compliance and attracting foreign investment.

Pakistan has historically faced challenges in these areas, but initiatives like the audit reforms by the Auditor General's office provide a positive example. Enhancing digital records and involving independent watchdogs can take this further. For traders and investors, transparent practices reduce risks, allowing market participants to assess true economic conditions without guesswork.

Actionable tips include:

• Establishing robust online portals for budget and spending reports

• Encouraging whistleblower protections to uncover corrupt practices

• Training government officials on ethics and compliance standards

Regulatory Improvements

Complex or outdated regulations often slow down business growth and scare off investors. Pakistan's regulatory framework, especially for new businesses and foreign investors, needs streamlining to cut red tape. Simplified licensing processes and timely approvals encourage entrepreneurship and ease of doing business.

The Securities and Exchange Commission of Pakistan (SECP) has made strides in this regard, yet more can be done to unify rules across provinces and sectors. Regulatory improvements not only promote economic activity but also reduce informal economic transactions that escape taxation.

Steps to consider:

• Developing a one-window operation for all regulatory approvals

• Periodically reviewing and updating business laws

• Enhancing digital platforms for compliance submissions

Enhancing Regional and International Cooperation

Trade Agreements

Trade deals act as bridges to expand markets and diversify exports. For Pakistan, signing and effectively implementing trade agreements means not just boosting export volumes but also fostering technology transfer and better standards.

Examples include the Pakistan-China Economic Corridor (CPEC) which has paved the way for enhanced trade routes and investment flows. Strengthening similar agreements with other neighbors and global partners could help alleviate trade imbalances by opening new demand avenues for Pakistani products.

To get the most out of trade agreements, the government should:

• Focus on sectors with export potential like textiles, IT, and agro-products

• Ensure compliance with international quality standards

• Facilitate exporters with better information and logistical support

Cross-border Investments

Attracting cross-border investments brings capital, technology, and expertise into Pakistan’s economy. This helps not only in expanding industries but also creating jobs. Countries like the UAE and China have been important investors, but Pakistan can widen this pool with better investor protection guarantees and incentives.

However, political stability and predictable economic policies must back these efforts. Investors look for low-risk environments, so implementing consistent policies and dispute resolution mechanisms is key.

Recommendations include:

• Offering tax holidays or reduced tariffs for foreign investments in priority sectors

• Streamlining processes for repatriation of profits

• Creating special economic zones with investor-friendly infrastructure

Clear policy reforms focusing on institutional strength and regional partnerships are the linchpins for Pakistan’s steady economic future. Without these, other improvements risk falling short.

In summary, this section underlines that improving Pakistan's economic run requires more than isolated efforts. By fixing foundational governance issues and opening doors to international collaborations, the country can reduce vulnerabilities and set a path that benefits all economic players involved.